Asian Kids Work Harder (Legault My Ego)

Posted By: Larry Fedoruk · 8/15/2012 8:14:00 AM

Francois Legault, the would-be Quebec premier has compared the young people of Quebec unfavorably to Asian children.

Quebec's provincial election campaign is infinitely more interesting than Ontario's ever was, with this challenger to Jean Charest's Liberals providing most of the fodder. Last week Mr. Legault suggested secondary schools in that province be open from 9-5, a serious and earnest debate which, it would seem, would hit union problems in this province.

ALL ASIANS ARE...?

Legault, a former Parti Quebecois member of the National Assembly of Quebec (their legislature) is now leader of the newly founded Coalition Avenir Quebec, coalition for the future of Quebec. He has spoken (as in VIDEO below) not so much of sovereignty but of fixing Quebec's economy, education, health, etc., a message that could resonate with Quebec voters.

And now this. Legault said young Quebecers are more interested in the "good life" and could learn a thing or two from their harder working Asian counterparts. He later elaborated, "If you have kids they'll tell you (the Asian students) are always first in class. One of my sons was telling me, 'Yes, but they have no life." Last year a controversial paper in the U.S. concluded Asian-American high school students averaged 13 hours of study per week over a calendar year, while others were 5.5 per week or less.

Jean Charest accused Legault (pictured above) of pandering to stereotypes and that Quebecers are hard-working people who do good things, including the young people. Is Charest just pandering for votes and totally in denial or is he right?

As a side bar, Quebecers have become famous for protecting symbols of their culture against an onslaught of immigrants wanting to preserve theirs. Quebecers want to keep their cherised traditions but can't seem to allow or understand why, others keep theirs. It's a dichotomy.

Is this just another issue of Quebecers generalizing, spouting off on anecdotal evidence, or does Legault make a point? By the way, in a touchy society we ARE allowed to say things about ethnic groups. We are allowed to observe and make sociological statements. We can ask questions out loud. It's not necessarily prejudicial or intolerant. LEAVE COMMENTS.

For other Larry Fedoruk blogs and features, click here.

Leave a comment:

showing all comments · Subscribe to comments
  1. HoaiPhai posted on 08/18/2012 09:19 AM
    Hmm, 50 seconds into this video Legault says, "We have to stop financing our programmes with borrowed money", but isn't freezing university tuition part of the PQ's platform? Could it be coming into power with the help of the youth vote is more important to the PQ than Quebec's fiscal health?

    I am an born-in-Montreal Anglophone and spent the first 45 of my life in that fine city. I also have a lot of Asian Montrealer friends. I think at least part of the credit for Asian kids' scholastic success (if this claim is born out by statistics and is not just Legault's kid's opinion) should go to Asian parents who encourage their children and make personal sacrifices to support their children's efforts.

    And as for Asian kids having "no life", some of my worst cases of "Sunday morning Molson malaise" was due to my hanging around with Asian friends on Saturday night. But this is just anecdotal evidence. Perhaps we could test whether Asian kids party just as hard as "real" Quebecers by changing the language laws so that Asian languages can be displayed on bars', cabarets', and other party venues' signs on an equal footing with French.

    Now I shouldn't be telling you this because I was sworn to secrecy by my Asian friends but their good grades are the result of magical powers contained within the kirpans, turbans, Buddhas, and Thiết Quan Âm charms they wear. Too bad for the Asian kids because where they will be allowed to wear these things will be limited by proposed PQ legislation. Between this legislation and relaxing the language laws to allow equality of all languages on businesses catering to "kids with a life", very soon the Asian kids' grades will drop to the Quebecois norm.

    Did Legault mention how many Asian kids his son or daughter invite to go out partying with him/her? Just curious.
  2. Larry Fedoruk posted on 08/18/2012 09:51 AM
    Well thanks for revealing the secrets. At least we all know now.
showing all comments
Programming1

Twitter